• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

New York Bagel Co. - Fresh Bagels & Coffee in Taunton, MA

New York Bagel Co., nestled inside a modern gas station on Bay Street in Taunton, offers an exceptional bagel experience. Known for their perfectly crunchy exterior and chewy interior, their bagels stand out with a wide variety of flavors and creative cream cheese options. The Turkey on Salsa Bagel is a standout, combining bold tastes with fresh ingredients that elevate a simple sandwich into a memorable meal. The café prides itself on fast, friendly service, including a convenient drive-thru, making it a top choice for a quick yet satisfying breakfast or lunch. Despite its unusual setting, the quality here makes it well worth the visit.

New York Bagel Co. at a glance

  • Address 1939 Bay St, Taunton, MA 02780, United States
  • Phone +1 508-386-3204
  • Restaurant type Coffee shop .
  • Popular for Breakfast , Lunch , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

New York Bagel Co.: Reviews & Ratings

Roy Burrill (Chef Roy)
5

the best bagels..Great variety. Don't mind waiting in the little bit of a line that was there. Atmosphere is a little weird. Being inside a gas station./convenience store. But it worked.

Justin Silva
5

They are fast with the food and comes out delicious I stop almost every morning and it makes my day start right. The manager was absolutely top notch and caring the workers are friendly can multitask over all go getters. I’m grateful the store was built and will be go till the end of time!!!

Eric B
5

These bagels are the best kind: a crunchy, crusty outside with a chewy inside. So many types of bagels and cream cheese to choose, plus tons of other options throughout the day. Helpful folks work there, and there's a drive-thru for those on the go. It's tucked into the new gas station on Bay Street and totally worth a visit.

Michael J Peckman
4

Great bagels, coffee and sandwiches. Usually busy and they prioritize the drive thru and wait inside orders seem to some time fall through the cracks. This has happened to me twice in a row. The chairs at their tables are not very comfortable and it is inside a gas station convenience store so not a very good vibe to sit and enjoy a bagel and coffee. Take out and enjoy the amazing bagels.

Jennifer Banks Oldfield
5

Headed over to Bjs or Tractor Farm Supply or grabbing 495?? Even if not, make the trip!!! The new New York Bagel Co has opened inside the newly built mobile station and has a huge selection of fresh bagels, which can also be made into sandwiches or pizza. There are so many cream cheese variations to choose from! I got a turkey sandwich on a salsa bagel, which came with my absolute favorite kind of pickle! My iced latte was just the way I like it! The bagels are crispy on the outside and nice and chewy on the inside with great flavor. So much better than fast food!!! #tauntonchamberofcommerce #ribboncutting #didyousaybagel?

Aliyah Holley
5

very nice workers, they were kind and gave off a good vibe, the food was delicious i got an everything bagel with cream cheese and it tasted delicious almost like it was fresh out the oven. would definitely recommend

Roger B.
5

It's really great to see an excellent business like this in our area! I have visited their Fall River location many times thru the years, and they did it again. Fantastic bagels! ..... Hats off to the ownership and the staff on a successful expansion.

paula smith
5

I go to New York Bagel almost every morning before work. It is very delicious and the customer service is awesome The kid angel that is always making my bagel is so kind and always makes my bagel so good, just the way i like it. The manager is always so helpful when i come in and just over all the food and employees are the best i love New York Bagel

Location

  • New York Bagel Co.
    New York Bagel Co.
    1939 Bay St, Taunton, MA 02780, United States Hotline: +1 508-386-3204

New York Bagel Co. is a hidden gem nestled inside a gas station at 1939 Bay St, Taunton, MA. Despite its unconventional location, this coffee shop delivers an authentic bagel experience that’s hard to beat. The standout item has to be the Turkey on Salsa Bagel, combining bold flavors with a perfectly textured bagel—crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside—that many customers rave about. The bagels themselves come in a wide variety, catering to diverse tastes, and are complemented by an impressive selection of cream cheeses and sandwich options, even pizza-style bagels.

The atmosphere may feel unusual given its setting inside a convenience store, but the efficiency and friendliness of the staff more than make up for it. The drive-thru service is a major plus for anyone on the go, ensuring quick delivery without sacrificing quality. Regulars like Justin Silva appreciate the fast service and welcoming team, highlighting how this spot brightens their mornings. Meanwhile, Chef Roy Burrill acknowledges the consistent quality and variety, even if it means waiting in line.

What truly sets New York Bagel Co. apart is the balance between traditional bagel craftsmanship and modern convenience. Each bagel boasts a satisfying crunch outside with a soft, chewy interior—a texture contrast that can be rare to find. Pairing this with flavorful fillings like turkey on a salsa bagel creates a memorable bite that goes beyond typical fast food offerings.

Though seating inside may be limited and not the most comfortable due to its gas station surroundings, the quality of the food turns this into a worthy stop for a takeout coffee and bagel fix. Whether you’re fueling up before a busy day or craving a quick yet satisfying snack, New York Bagel Co. stands out in Taunton as a reliable source of hearty, flavorful bagels with a personal touch.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments